10 Myths about Google Chrome Browser

Svetlana Gladkova,


Google Chrome browser logoSince everyone seems to be determined to cover Google’s newly-launched Chrome browser on every side, I have decided to join in after I’ve been playing with the browser for a few days and reading literally hundreds of posts about it everywhere. This post is intended to demystify Google’s browser a little and show that some of the hype around it is merely about Google actually launching a browser instead of the innovative approaches implemented in the browser itself - no matter how hard Google may try to persuade everyone the browser is full of entirely new ideas not seen anywhere else.

Myth 1: Separate processes for each tab

This seems to be the most hyped feature of Google Chrome - the one everyone seems to be very excited about after having Firefox crashes caused by a process running in one of the tabs. Unfortunately, there is some disappointment here as this approach is far from new and it is even used in Internet Explorer 8 beta - the browser everyone thinks Chrome is intended to compete with. Microsoft named this “tab isolation” and the feature description reads: “If a website or add-on causes a tab to crash in Internet Explorer 8, only that tab is affected. The browser itself remains stable and other tabs remain unaffected, thereby minimizing any disruption to your browsing experience.” Does not it sound familiar after all those reviews of Chrome everyone must have read already?

Google Chrome individual processes in tabs

Myth 2: New V8 JavaScript virtual machine

Sure, everyone knows we rely on various JavaScript-powered applications quite a lot these days. And everyone seems to be aware that the way existing browsers handle JavaScript code is far from perfect and needs to be improved. And everyone is not only Google - guys from Firefox are smart enough as well and they’ve been in web browsing business long enough to realize what the market needs now. So they have also promised to add a virtual JavaScript machine to Firefox - as soon as in version 3.1 actually.

Google Chrome virtual JavaScript Machine

Myth 3: Private browsing

Ah, Google is a smart company, smart enough that people visit porn sites more frequently than they claim. And private browsing that does not leave any traces of browsing on a user’s computer is sure something that could be appealing to a huge portion of web population. And Google, the smart Google, is here with a solution: Incognito for browsing. And while this sounds cool, it is nothing new with the same feature already available in Internet Explorer 8 - but under another name: InPrivate.

Myth 4: Privacy

We’ve heard authoritative opinions that Chrome is not sending any information from a user’s computer to Google’s servers but this myth was also debunked pretty soon. The thing is that Chrome’s address and search bar “Omnibox” with auto-suggestion enabled actually sends all the characters typed by a user to Google servers (even before the user hits enter) if Google is set as a default search engine. And even after Google provides suggestions based on those keystrokes, Google will keep about 2% of this information along with the IP addresses that send those characters to Google. This is certainly supposed to raise concerns in those users already worried about the volume of information Google already has for almost every internet user.

Myth 5: Malware and phishing protection

Google Chrome is very proud of constantly downloading information on websites that are known to be insecure for a web user to visit and warning the users of potential malware and phishing threats. This sounds innovative and useful enough but actually Internet Explorer seems to already offer something very similar as a SmartScreen Filter for the very same purpose of protecting a user from malware and phishing attacks.

Google Chrome anti-phishing protection

Internet Explorer 8 beta 2 SmartScreen screenshot

Myth 6: Domain Highlighting

While many of liked how Chrome highlights domain names to help us easier understand exactly what site we are browsing. But I guess those surprised are simply those web users that have not seen Internet Explorer 8 yet as Microsoft’s beta browser offers exactly the same highlighting functionality:

Internet Explorer 8 beta:

Domain highlighting in Internet Explorer 8 beta 2

Google Chrome:

Google Chrome domain highlighting

Myth 7: Groups for tabs

It is no doubt a great idea for Chrome to introduce groups for tabs. Groups mean that when you open a link from one of your tabs, it will be opened in a tab located right next to the current one instead of as the last rightmost tab. This is intended to keep all the tabs connected to each other grouped in bundles together. Very cool and definitely a needed enhancement for tabbed browsing but unfortunately not introduced by Google - take a look at Internet Explorer 8 again, will you?

Grouping tabs in Internet Explorer 8 beta 2

Myth 8: Improved find on page

Same here - an exact copy of Internet Explorer functionality. The idea is that when you click Ctrl+F to find some text on the page you are currently browsing, the browser will start searching immediately instead of waiting for you to type in the entire search term and hit ‘Enter’. Besides, all the matches will be highlighted immediately instead of making you go from the current to the next one. And this is not pioneered by Chrome either - Internet Explorer 8 has exactly the same functionality. The only difference between the two browsers is that Chrome highlights the first match in orange and the rest of them in yellow while IE highlights the first one in blue with the rest of them in… yellow as well.

Google Chrome:

Google Chrome highlighting matches for find on page

Microsoft Internet Explorer 8:

Internet Explorer 8 highlights matches in find on page

Myth 9: Resizing input text boxes

It must look like a cool functionality that you can resize the input box when you type a comment somewhere on Reddit or FriendFeed. But Google is not the first to the game with this enhancement either: Safari has been doing it for a while now and I believe it has something to do with Chrome and Safari using the same WebKit rendering engine.

Myth 10: Standards compatibility

Sure, when Google launches something we expect immediately that it will be the most advanced something meeting all the industry standards. Unfortunately there’s an unpleasant surprise for us here: Chrome does not show perfect results in ACID2 and ACID3 standards compatibility tests. And while it performs better than stable versions of other popular browsers, it is still outperformed by development releases of Firefox, Opera, and Safari. So no matter how advanced this one may be, we should not expect it to be 100% compliant and actually the best browser of those currently in development.

So after demystifying some of the latest and greatest approaches to browsing in Chrome I can say that it is absolutely not visible that Google is so much of an innovator in this particular case: they simply took the best features and ideas from existing browsers (or just listened to what users wanted browsers to do) and wrapped them into a very pompous launch of Chrome.

Besides, it must mean that we as web users simply tend to love everything about Google much more than anything about Microsoft so we have barely noticed very similar features in Microsoft’s Internet Explorer 8 beta but now that Google introduces them we have overhyped them as much as we could. Now tell me why our affection towards the company behind a product is more important than the product itself?